However, this clip of him (hypothetically) threatening a 12-year-old's cat is hilarious.
Speaking from Utah via video sat alongside her dad, she explained on Good Morning Britain, which is on ITV every weekday morning 6-8.30am: "I like hunting because it's something that's been in my family a long time.
"And I really enjoy the taste of the meat we kill."
She's received death threats because of her controversial hunting selfies. Explaining, she said: "I'm very upset that people would value an animal's life over another person's.
"I try to ignore most of the comments I get but I do read some by accident. I just try to not let them get to me.
"It won't stop me hunting. I will always hunt. It's something that thousands of people do and it's never going to stop."
When Piers went in by asking if they'd be upset if he killed Aryanna's cat, the family were furious. Piers explained that there was a level of irony in the fact that, on her Facebook profile, she's proudly stood next to animals she's shot, but also there's pictures where she's cuddling her cat.
Her dad, Eli, retorted: "That's a trick question. We have never killed a pet. That's a derogatory question and it falls into the same category as the death threats. We would never think to kill somebody's pet!"
What do you think? Let us know in the comments below.
Featured image credit: ITV News/PA Images
Source: The LAD Bible